Wednesday, April 25, 2007

Question: Is the use of torture ever justified in dealing with criminals and terrorists? Discuss this in the light or the arguments raised in the 2 articles and substantiate your ideas with examples of your own.

The use of torture was never justified in dealing with criminals and terrorists. For example, in the case of 911 many years ago, the detainess and suspects were tortured during custody to spill information. You can imagine the pain, agony and depressions they felt at that time. you may sympatise with them. But when ou start to think about the loss of lives of the victims, the sufferings of the victim's families and the awful carnage of a nation's broken heart, their screams sound like justice. You then think that they deserved all this. but they are humans as well, all alive and breathing. How can anyone bear to inflict torture upon them? The only difference between them and us is that they have done peple wrong. The use of torture is painful and unbearable.

Another question you may ask is why torture when it does not work, or the results are ineffective? The main aim of using torture to deal with criminals is to get information to solce cases or identify more suspects. But through evidences in the article, torture doesn't always bring about the results. First example i would cite is the case of Abu Zubaydah, in march 2002. He was used as an experiment in righteous brutality and in the end, very little was produced. His interrogation, according to those overseeing it, yielded little from threats and torture. He named countless irrelevant targets to stop the pain. Another few more examples would be Ramzi BinalShibh, an erudite killer who provided little information under extreme dures, and 911 planner Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, provided jumbled information that is not worth anything. It shows that torture does not guarantee results at all. Torture also accumulates unnecessary costs, and also, there is a loss of democracy's moral authority and the poisoning of any eventual legal procedding, which, of course, would disallow evidence gained through torture. There might be objections, and cries from people who cannot stand torture or anything gory happening to anyone.

With these examples, i conclude with my stand, that the use of torture is never justified in dealing with criminals.

No comments: