Sunday, July 1, 2007

GP Holiday Blog Assignment

Question: In the context of Singapore's Multi-Racial society, where there is cultural and religious pluralism, which author's view do you think should be adopted?
Write a response of at least 300 words and 2 content paragraphs, and include materials materials from both articles as well as your own knowledge and experience.

I would support Zsofia Szilagyi's views, if the context were to be applied to Singapore's society. Zsofia Szilagyi believes that more focus should be placed on social responsibility. It can be seen from his statement, "The press needs to serve the ever-evolving public interest, and it needs to do so by focusing on responsibility" Singapore is a country, where multi-racialism is a fragile concept. It is so fragile that the Singapore government even imposed laws to protect the different races, and also to punish those who try to disrupt the peace among the people. People from different races have their own set of identities, and their own cultures. They value their roots, and this is very close to their heart, if someone tries to make fun, or critisise it, people will naturally act against it because of their self-defence. It's like someone invading your personal feelings and hurting them. Social responsibility is needed for peace and stability. If anyone is given the freedom to write what they think, and people get angry, what would happen? Fights, riots, everything terrorizing you can think of. This point is agreed with Zsofia Szilagyi's point,"existing societal and political tensions can be inflamed instantly through the transfer of messages from one cultural context to another".

Looking through Peter Singer's views. He has a point about freedom of speech and democracy. His point is, that freedom of speech is essential to democratic regimes, and without that freedom, human progress will always run up against a basic roadblock. This includes freedom to say what everyone else believes to be false, and even what many people find offensive. I only agree with this to a certain extent.
If everyone is given freedom of speech, this world will be a terrible place of misunderstandings and quarrels. Freedom of speech should be allowed, in the sense that everyone's opinions and views are taken into consideration. But there should be a limit set. Like, a person should be punished for saying things about other races, or a generalization made about them. I mean, why hurt your fellow Singaporeans?

With multi racialism being such a fragile concept in Singapore, it is impossible to actually implement freedom of speech, unless all Singaporeans think of comments as a way to improvement and understanding. But we are all humans, and sadly, most of us don't see it that way.

-394 words

No comments: